Another take on the value of Classics

These are the closing words of chapter 5, 'The Place of Classics in Education,' from The Aims of Education.

Europe is always flying apart because of the diverse explosive character of its inheritance, and coming together because it can never shake off that impress of unity it has received from Rome. The history of Europe is the history of Rome curbing the Hebrew and the Greek, with their various impulses of religion, and of science, and of art, and of quest for material comfort, and of lust of domination, which are all at daggers drawn with each other. The vision of Rome is the vision of the unity of civilisation.

--Alfred North Whitehead (1929)

Images from Livy (10)

'Tapestry of the History of Scipio: The Battle of Zama'. Giulio Romano (model), Francesco Penni (preparatory cartoon), François Bonnemer (Gobelins cartoon). Housed in Louvre. Here is what the Louvre's page for the work says:

Tapestry of the History of Scipio: the Battle of Zama

This is the tenth and last panel in a series the cartoons for which had been copied by François Bonnemer from a Brussels tapestry in the Royal Furniture Repository. The latter was itself based on a large tapestry depicting Scipio's military exploits, made for François I in 1535. Eight tapestries in the present series are on display at the Louvre; the other two are in the collections of the Mobilier National.

Description
The depiction of the battle

The scene, which is based on Livy's account of the second Punic War in his History of Rome (XXX, 33, 4-16), depicts the last battle pitting Scipio and the Roman army against the Carthaginians. Elephants in the Carthaginian army's front lines are charging the Romans, toppling men and horses. On the left, an elephant startled by the blare of a trumpet and a horn turns on its own camp. In the foreground, Scipio, wearing a starry blue mantle, leads his men, urging them to push back the enemy with swords and javelins.The border along the sides and lower edge features a broad garland of flowers, fruits, small animals, and frolicking children. The upper part consists of an architrave, probably to comply with the dimensions requested by the first patron to commission a tapestry on this theme, the Maréchal de Saint-André, whose arms grace the upper corners.

A glimpse into art history

François I owned a twenty-two-panel tapestry depicting the heroic deeds and ultimate triumph of Scipio Africanus. "Scipio the Great", finely woven and particularly rich in gold threads, was widely admired and copied several times. Jacques d'Albon, seigneur of Saint-André and maréchal de France since 1547, commissioned from Brussels, probably around 1558, a ten-panel history of Scipio depicting the Roman general's heroic deeds, six of which were copied directly from the king's tapestry. In the following century, it entered Mazarin's and, later, Louis XIV's collections, and, in the late seventeenth century, Louvois had it reproduced at the Gobelins, along with other Renaissance tapestries from the Royal Furniture Repository. During the Revolution, the panels were sold and dispersed. In 1797, François I's tapestry was burned along with other tapestries from the Royal Furniture Repository in order to recover the precious metals. This "copy" was preserved in the national collections and offers a partial but relatively accurate glimpse of the famous tapestry, since destroyed.

An innovative composition

Most of the models for the tapestry can be attributed to Giulio Romano, an artist who did a great deal of decorative painting in Italy, as well as drawings for tapestries. His colleague, Gian Francesco Penni, made preliminary cartoons for the artists who painted the full-scale cartoons. Several institutions, including the Louvre, have drawings Giulio made of the victory, as well as studies that can be related to the heroic deeds. The composition of the Battle of Zama tapestry is both original and bold. Traditionally, battle scenes had been presented in profile. Here, the artist shows the enemy bearing down on the viewer, putting him on the same plane as the Roman vanguard, thereby drawing him into the heart of the battle.

Documentation

Jules Romain. L'Histoire de Scipion. Tapisseries et dessins, Paris, Galeries nationales du Grand Palais, 1978.Lefebure Amaury, La galerie de Scipion, feuillet Louvre 6 27Lefebure Amaury, "La Bataille de Zama, tapisserie d'après Jules Romain", in Carthage, l'histoire, sa trace et son écho, Paris, Galeries nationales du Grand Palais, 1995, pp.164-169.

Essentials of Antiquity

The other day I was trying to think of a list of literary works from antiquity besides the Bible that could be described as 'essential' based on the criterion that most (or many) people have at least heard of them by title and/or author, even if that's all they know about them. It must, it seems to me, be a rather short list. Here is what I've come up with for the Greek side.

Aesop, Fables
Aristotle, Politics and, perhaps, Poetics
Homer, Iliad and Odyssey
Plato, Republic
Sophocles, Oedipus the King

Thoughts?

"Perhaps you are lazy ..."

I'm just now memorizing this in order to respond to students:

(From The Relation of Latin to Practical Life by Frances Ellis Sabin, 1913)

Transcription (for those without graphics):

ANSWERS TO SOME COMMON OBJECTIONS TO THE STUDY OF LATIN

1. "It's too hard!"

Perhaps it's not so hard as you think. Perhaps you are lazy and do not like to do anything that does not immediately interest you and so calls for an effort of your will. Anyone who has had much experience in life will tell you that very few things that are really worth while come easily. Do you know Herbert Spencer's famous definition of education: "to accustom myself to do the thing I know I ought to do at the time when I ought to do it, whether I feel like doing it or not"?

Number 1 is the best of all, so we'll leave it there. I'm actually going to turn this into a poster.

One problem though: was it Herbert 'survival of the fittest' Spencer who said that, or another famed Darwinist of sorts T.H. Huxley?

Was ist das?

I've never wondered until now what exactly 'kleine Schriften' means, so I'm putting it to the kind visitors who've helped me in the past.

'Small' in the sense of notes, unpublished papers, and the like? Or can this include things like journal articles as opposed to monographs and other 'big' works? What exactly is small, semantically, about the works included? My dictionaries are no help.